Warblers on the Glenolden Christmas Bird Count

When you think about Christmas Bird Counts in our neck of the woods, you conjure up images of cold, overcast days, flitting chickadees and kinglets, wood edges busy with scratching juncos and sparrows and Red-tailed Hawks and Turkey Vultures patrolling the skies. One doesn’t usually think of warblers.

Okay, we all hope to find that rare warbler that’s been found only once or twice on previous counts, but, if we’re lucky, we usually settle on finding a Yellow-rumped Warbler. When we do come across a warbler on the count it brightens up the day, especially if there is a flash of yellow or bright green against a gray or snowy background.

In the ninety-five year history of the Glenolden CBC, eleven warbler species have been recorded. A high of six species were found on the 1983 count and five species were recorded on five counts.

Before reading further, here is a list of warbler species found on the Glenolden CBC so far. Of course, on this list, Yellow-rumped Warbler has been found most frequently, but see if you can figure out how the remaining ten species rank in frequency.

List of warblers found on the Glenolden CBC:

Orange-crowned Warbler

Nashville Warbler

Yellow-rumped Warbler

Black-throated Green Warbler

Pine Warbler

Palm Warbler

Black and white Warbler

Ovenbird

Common Yellowthroat

Wilson's Warbler

Yellow-breasted Chat

Species recorded on the CBC listed by frequency of occurrence.

Yellow-rumped "Myrtle" Warbler

Yellow-rumped Warbler – This is the default winter resident warbler in our area. It has been recorded on 62 counts with an amazing high count of 63 in 1984. Even though these birds are quite numerous in November, their numbers decrease quickly as winter progresses and by January they can be down right hard to find. 

Common Yellowthroat (female)

Common Yellowthroat – Has been recorded on 33 counts beginning in 1940 and is mostly found in the Coastal Plain portion of the count circle usually along the Delaware River or Darby Creek. In Delaware Co., there are few January records and I’m not aware of any February sightings. The eBird map for December (all years) show the occurrence in the east from Maine to Florida with higher concentration (darker purple) from the Carolinas south.

Common Yellowthroat - December eBird Records (all years).

Palm Warbler

Palm Warbler – This species winters regularly from coastal southern MD southward, so it is not surprising that it has been recorded on the CBC 14 times. What is surprising to me is that it has not been recorded more frequently. Highest total so far is 13 in 1999, which I think will be hard to top. Once again, most reports are from the Coastal Plain. The eBird map shows a heavy concentration in Georgia and Florida with declining numbers northward. With these concentrations in the east, I would expect Palm Warblers to be found frequently.

Palm Warbler - December records from eBird (all years).

Pine Warbler – A fairly common and regular winter resident in small numbers from southern Maryland to Florida and westward to Texas. It has been found on the CBC twelve times since 1974 with a high count of three in 2010.

Pine Warbler - Marcus Hook, Glenolden CBC 2009

They have been found both in the Coastal Plain and the Piedmont portions of the count circle. December occurrence in North America is heavily concentrated in the southeast especially from the Carolinas to the Gulf states.

Pine Warbler - December eBird Records (all years).

Yellow-breasted Chat – A rare winter resident along the eastern seaboard. Found on the CBC eight times since 1953 with a high count of two also in 1953.

Yellow-breasted Chat

There are a few additional records in the count circle for December and January, but no records for February and March. This species can sometimes be secretive but responds well to squeaking and pishing, so I don’t think it is being overlooked.

Yellow-breasted Chat - December eBird records (all years).

Orange-crowned Warbler – Rare winter resident in the mid-Atlantic states becoming more common in the Carolinas and especially in Florida and along the Gulf to Texas.

Orange-crowned Warbler - December eBird records (all years).

With the high concentrations of this species along the coast and in the southeast, I would expect more occurrences, but, this is a skulking drab green bird and can be overlooked, so it’s a great day when one is found.

Orange-crowned Warbler

Usually, if any warbler species is found on the CBC, it is generally one from the group above.

These next five species have occurred on the count four times or less and we should consider ourselves extremely lucky to cross paths with one of them in mid-December. Having said this, these five species all winter in small numbers in Florida, so potentially we haven’t seen the last of them.

Ovenbird – This species has been found on the CBC four times. The first sighting was of a bird feeding on a peanut butter log in a backyard in Swarthmore by Helen McWilliams and Lynn Mitchell in 1978.

An astonishing two birds were found at feeders in 1984, a single bird was on the 1987 count and another was found at a feeder in Media by Grace Felton on the 1991 CBC. Ovenbirds winter in small numbers in Florida but become scarce north of there.

Ovenbird - December eBird records (all years).

Black-and-white Warbler – Single individuals have been found twice. The first was found by yours truly as the bird was feeding in a brushy edge with a flock of sparrows in Woodlyn, Ridley Township. Needless to say, I was stunned and being a teenager without a camera I knew there was no way it would be accepted. It was and I was thrilled.

Black-and-white Warbler

I think the fact that I also came across a Snowy Owl earlier in the day and that some of my mentors at the time got to enjoy it, played in my favor. It was the first and only time I’ve seen a Black-and-white Warbler and a Snowy Owl in the same day.  The second report was of a bird found in Media on the 1983 count. Once again, this is a species that winters in the East in small numbers from about the Carolinas south and can very well turn up on the CBC again.

Black-and-white Warbler - December eBird records (all years)

Black-throated Green Warbler – Single birds have been found twice. Erica Brendel, Ed Fingerhood and Chris Walters discovered the first on the grounds of Elwyn Institute in 1994. An excellent description and drawing were submitted which eliminated the similar Townsend’s and Hermit Warblers.

Black-throated Green Warbler

Doris McGovern and Noel Kelly found the second bird at John Heinz NWR on the 2012 CBC. The eBird map shows a fairly restrictive winter range mostly in Florida and the Texas Gulf coast and Rio Grande Valley. Single birds have appeared on many of our neighboring counts and this species is still passing through our area in mid-October, so despite the restrictive range, it may appear again.

Black-throated Green Warbler - December eBird records (all years)..

Nashville Warbler

Nashville Warbler – This species has been found once on the 1999 CBC. Sharon Pulcinella and I found it as we were driving by some dilapidated buildings in Marcus Hook. We saw some flashes of yellow fly across the front of the car and we immediately pulled over and checked it out. We saw a small group of birds feeding on some insects on the sun drenched warm wall of one of the buildings creating a favorable micro-habitat. At once, we saw a few Palm Warblers and then another bird with bright yellow underparts a greenish back and a definite eyering. Not only were we elated with the Nashville but we also thrilled with six Palm Warblers. 

Nashville Warbler - December eBird records.

The eBird map shows a concentration of sightings in Florida and Texas, but, there is also a cluster of early December records in the mid-Atlantic, so there is a good chance we will see it again.

Wilson's Warbler 

Wilson’s Warbler – This is another warbler that has been discovered on the count only once. A team of birders from the Academy of Natural Sciences of Philadelphia covering the John Heinz NWR on the 1983 CBC found it.

This species, as shown on the map, winters in Florida, the Gulf states and southeast Texas. We might have to get lucky to find another.

Wilson's Warbler - December eBird records (all years).

Warblers on nearby CBCs.

A number of our neighboring CBCs have also recorded multiple warbler species, including some that have not been found on the Glenolden CBC. The following warblers have been documented on nearby counts but not the Glenolden CBC yet.

Northern Waterthrush

Northern Waterthrush – Audubon CBC (includes parts of Chester & Montgomery Cos.). The eBird map shows a very restrictive winter range in North America. The range is mostly Florida, Texas and the Gulf coast. This one will be hard, but still possible.

Northern Waterthrush - December eBird records (all years)

Kentucky Warbler – Elverson CBC (includes parts of Chester and Berks Cos.). This one is real mind-blower as it doesn't winter in North America. Chances are very, very slim for a repeat performance.

Kentucky Warbler

Kentucky Warbler - December eBird records (all years).

American Redstart – Southern Lancaster Co. (includes parts of Lancaster and Chester Cos.).

American Redstart - December eBird records (all years).

American Redstart

I'm a bit surprised that this species has not yet been recorded on the Glenolden CBC. It winters regularly in Florida and I would think a late, straggling migrant might turn up within the count circle.

Cape May Warbler

Cape May Warbler – Central Bucks CBC & Pennypack Valley CBC.

This is definitely a species that can show up on the CBC. This bird winters in Florida and is one of the later fall migrant warblers to pass through our area. I have one record of a single bird on December 6th in the Crozer Arboretum, Upland.

Cape May Warbler - December eBird Records (all years).

Blackburnian Warbler

Blackburnian Warbler - Lancaster CBC.

Another real zinger. Very rare in North America in December and I think there is very little chance that it will make an appearance.

Blackburnian Warbler - December eBird Records (all years).

Black-throated Blue Warbler – Lancaster CBC & Wilmington CBC. Winters regularly in Florida so it's appearance on two neighboring CBCs is not surprising.  

Black-throated Blue Warbler - December eBird Records (all years).

Black-throated Blue Warbler

Yellow-throated Warbler - Southern Lancaster Co. (includes parts of Lancaster and Chester Cos.). I'm surprised this species has not yet been on the Glenolden CBC. They winter in good numbers in the southeast and can be very late fall migrants through the Delaware Valley.

Yellow-throated Warbler - December eBird Records (all years).

Yellow-throated Warbler

There are also four additional warbler species that winter in FL and the Gulf Coast but have yet to be recorded not only on the Glenolden CBC but on any of the neighboring counts.

Northern Parula - As you can see from the map, this species winters throughout Fl and northward to SC and west along the Gulf Coast.

Northern Parula

Because of that, I suspect that there is potential for this bird to show up on the Glenolden CBC

Northern Parula - December eBird Records

Magnolia Warbler - A species that winters in south FL and east TX and is also a bit of a late migrant through our area could possibly be a candidate for the Glenolden CBC. A single Magnolia Warbler was found on the Cape May CBC in 2014. 

Magnolia Warbler

Magnolia Warbler - December eBird Records.

Yellow Warbler - I'm surprised this bird has not yet turned up on the Glenolden CBC especially since there has been a December report from John Heinz NWR and a mid-January record from the Philadelphia Mid-Winter Census. 

Yellow Warbler

There is some thought that these very late Yellow Warblers may be of the duller Alaska race rubiginosa which are still migrating through our area from parts very far north.

Yellow Warbler - December eBird Records.

Prairie Warbler - This is one species that I am really surprised has not been found on any CBC in our area. 

                                                                   Prairie Warbler

They can usually be found in small numbers in winter in coastal VA and the Carolinas and in moderate numbers in FL and along the Gulf Coast and east TX. Interestingly, a Prairie Warbler was reported on the 2008 Glenolden CBC from Hildacy Farm but the National Audubon Regional Reviewer did not feel the documentation submitted was adequate for a positive identification and removed the species from the count.  I was compiler for the 2008 CBC and I thought the documentation was correct. So this may be one that got away but I think will be back. 

                                                                 Prairie Warbler - December eBird Records.

I did not discuss the three most likely vagrant "western" warblers that might be found on the Glenolden CBC, Townsend's, Hermit and Black-throated Gray as they are strictly vagrants and not species that normally winter in the southeast United States. 

Finding a warbler on the CBC is both fun and exciting because when that flash of yellow or green appears your heart will start thumping and the feeling of cold that's been tormenting you all day will rapidly melt away.  

Marco Island and Tigertail Beach by Gary Becker

Susan with Royal Terns, Black Skimmers and Willet

           

        It’s hard to believe that until the 1960’s Marco Island was almost totally uninhabited except for mosquitoes.  In fact during Hurricane Donna in 1960 the island was submerged under 12 feet of water.  Now most of the island is covered with 1960ish tract homes giving it a retro feel. Crescent Beach occupies most of the island’s west coast.  Its northern most part is called Tigertail Beach and is one of the most important sites in south western Florida for wintering shorebirds. 

 

Tigertail Beach with its Shorebirds

         The beach and lagoon are constantly changing in response to the currents but at low tide the mudflats are revealed and can be easily explored. When we first arrived early morning January 25 there were no visitors present and the tide was out. To my surprise I immediately spotted a number of  Wilson’s Plovers(a lifer for me). 

Wilson's Plover showing off its hunker of a bill

         In addition to the Wilson’s there were Snowy(another recent lifer), Piping, Semipalmated and Black-bellied Plovers, Western and Least Sandpipers, Dunlin, Short-billed Dowitchers, Lesser Yellowlegs and a Reddish Egret. 

Snowy Plover with black eye spot

Piping Plover - compare bill shape to Snowy above

Reddish Egret

         There were a few Red Knots one of which had a band on each leg. 

Winter plumaged Red Knots

  

 

Red Knot with flags on legs

          While photographing and enjoying some great looks at the 2 new life birds we were suddenly interrupted by groups of kite-surfers noisily trudging across the mudflats and then the dunes to reach the ocean. The birds quickly flew away so I was lucky to get in my half hour of birding before the crowds arrived.   In contrast to the less developed Tigertail Beach, the southern part of Crescent Beach is definitely a bathing beach. It’s surrounded by hotels and condos but there is municipal parking for folks just visiting. We spent part of the day on this beach with some friends who took advantage of the great shelling there and I believe it to be as good as can be found on Sanibel Island.  Royal Terns and Black Skimmers were numerous along with several  Magnificent  Frigatebirds and a Peregrine Falcon.  

 

Magnificent Frigatebird

            A week later Susan and I returned to search out the Burrowing Owls that nest on the island and are plentiful in spite of the rampant development.  When we arrived on the island we were side tracked by an open air market a few blocks off the main street. As it turned out this was a fortuitous event since we really had no idea where to go to locate these owls. There were lots of different vendors selling anything from T-shirts to Tacos but one exhibitor was displaying his wildlife photos including several of our target bird: the Burrowing Owl.  On inquiring he told me he shot the pictures only a few miles away.  He directed me to the Mackle Library and suggested I check out the surrounding streets and watch for roped off  areas on vacant lots.  Sure enough many of the undeveloped residential lots within blocks of the library had small roped off areas and several Burrowing Owls standing next to their burrows. 

 

Burrowing Owls

         

“Sibley” says they are nocturnal hunters but they will perch outside their homes in the daylight.  Really a most interesting bird and another lifer for me.  Marco Island is only 30 minutes south of Naples and is on my must see places for birding, shelling and hanging out on a beautiful beach.

 

Least Sandpiper

Western Sandpiper

Dunlin